Cast of Pirates of Penzance
| Pirate King | Joseph P. Necci |
| Samuel, His Lieutenant | Michael J. Widmer |
| Frederic | David Kaiser |
| Ruth, A Pirate Maid | Leslie Hochman |
| Pirates | David Clarke |
| Matthew Gibbons | Matthew Gibbons |
| Christopher J. Guell | |
| A.J. Meeker | |
| Frank Picone | |
| Ivan Rushfield | |
| Tom Schumann | |
| Donnie Unkel | |
| George J. Wallace | |
| Major-General' Daughters | Mona Carol |
| Dotti Friis | |
| Michelle Krainski | |
| Alicia Picone | |
| Valerie Van Hoosier | |
| Edith | Amy Levine |
| Kate | Megan McDonagh |
| Isabel | Robin Weaver |
| Mabel | Jo Ellen Miller |
| Major General | John Wyckoff |
| The Sergeant | Kevin Gunther |
| Constables | Matthew Gibbons |
| Christopher J. Guell | |
| A.J. Meeker | |
| Bill O'Donnell | |
| Lou Pucci* | |
| Ivan Rushfield | |
| Donnnie Unkel | |
| Mathew Weisfeld |
* Appears courtesy of Actors Equity Association